Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Doug Bowker's avatar

Ah... The line between overdoing it and doing it as well as possible. Perfectionism can be a defense against the uncertainty of the world on one hand, and on the other hand: Precision that is more like an act of love; a gift of our talents and efforts. Like so many things, we can't ever reach a universal conclusion on the topic because for every perfectionist using it to stave off anxiety, I can point you to person who uses messiness, looseness, or being "easygoing" for the exact same reasons: it's an insulation against uncertainty. Or as the Buddha pointed out: "An instrument strung to tightly will break; an instrument strung to loosely can't make sound." Thus was born the Middle Path.

In any case, we wouldn't chide Beethoven, or Leonardo Da Vinci for being perfectionists? I (and so many others long before me) love the Italian author Elena Ferrante, and in interviews she has often stated that she's written 10X or more than what she's submitted for publication. For her, writing must come from a kind of utter honesty and absolute inner truth; anything less and it all falls apart. Obviously, many, if not most, of the hard sciences depend on exacting precision...

So to me, whether perfect or precise, it comes to What it is, Who it's for and Why you are doing it. I'm known in our house as a definite perfectionist when it comes to gift wrapping. For me, it's a good example of "precision as an act of giving." For me, to give a thoughtful gift AND to put exacting care into its wrapping is one and the same. As important, it's something I am "able" to do; partly from a creative nature, partly from all of the skills I picked up at art school. Thus to not wrap a gift "perfectly" (or with precision) would be a little like ingratitude towards the universe.

In other cases, I've learned to look out for aspects of perfectionism that's more a kind of "control" or a way to avoid certain feelings. Again, it can go either way depending on the person, the trick being knowing which applies to yourself.

Expand full comment
Kathie Mell's avatar

HannahLynn, I am reading your Musings. Am also distracted by my StoryWorth; stories about where I have been.

Your precision work has always been an amazing adventure to be a part of..... ever since you were 2, watching the clock, in anticipation of your See&Know Bible Study. You came home with a verse and a song to sing.

Nancy's comment inspired by Levertov brought to mind my solo trip north in 2008....... my dream, your interpretation.... which was so positive and faith-filled. You have gone to places that I will never go.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?